This is most likely the 3 areas that will be judged; style, technical and variation.
How can you say JK is not creative?
I am also a block freestyler and what you said about clutches, catches and creativity fit under style and variation.
The freestylers you named would make great judges but I can't satisfy everyone's request; imagine every competitor requesting for a different judge, it would be chaos so I went with my own instinct.
The judges will judge all aspects and areas of the video and to me, 3 judges provide more opinion instead of just one judge which gives more opportunities for the competitors just like you said, so one judge won't be bias according to his style.
You don't consider blocks lowers? Tbh I would be pissed off if someone told me that what I was doing wasn't lowers. Blocks is just a sub category of lowers; just another form of lowers.
How are you going to judge lowers, uppers and sits as an individual criteria without guidelines? For example, is it going to be judged by how difficult your lowers tricks are or by how stylish your lowers are?
What about people that don't do blocks? Will they get 0?
Finally, when you say judge creativity.. Do you mean executing new tricks or just creative variation (in which case, falls under variety). If it's by new tricks, then blocks, clutches catches wouldn't be creativity and everyone would get a low score for that field unless someone executes a trick never to be seen before. Variation on the other hand, covers blocks, clutches and catches into consideration which I think is what you are trying to say.
I tried my best so that every style can be judged fairly and not be bias towards one particular style.
Hope you understand. Sorry for the long post.
