I did this one a LONG while ago on soccerpulse. maybe it's relevant?
What qualities make a legend?
Football legends… Some people revere them as Gods, others look to them for inspiration, and to some they are forgotten things, fading away into time, rather like a forgotten dream, vague and mysterious. But what makes a legend? They are/were all only footballers after all, are/were they not? They all were once humans but have now risen to the status of venerable kings. What set them apart from other footballers? What qualities made them legends of the beautiful game?
First and foremost comes the most important and basic of a quality that makes a football legend – skills. If the player is not good at playing football, nothing else is going to matter. Has a player who hadn’t any skills become football legends? I don’t think so. No skills, no respect. It would be hard even to make it in the business. But there are many skillful players and only a handful of legends. How is this so? Legends always bring something extra to the team. Maradona was an out-of-this-world dribbler with uncanny offensive abilities such as shooting and even passing. Pele was a nearly perfect header of the ball, had great dribbling and near perfect shooting and passing. Bobby Moore had an amazing ability to read the play and defend accordingly. Great players have great skills but legends such as the above had special skills which surpassed all others and put them on a level of their own.
Now we must also consider, sure a lot of players were skillful but not remembered as legends. It’s true that legends were on a level of their own but surely there were some that drew near to their levels and still didn’t “make it”. Who remembers the name Nobby Stiles? Clodoaldo? Who remembers Riva? If you go up to a random person on the streets and asked them about Neeskens or Ortega would they understand what you are talking about? No, but were you to talk about Pele or Maradona or Zidane or Ronaldo it would be a different story altogether. Sure you can have all the skills in the world, and sure you could win a lot of trophies and titles, but it’s the
moments people will remember. Take Baggio for example and the famous quote about him from Sports Illustrated – “His legend had been built not on titles but on moments.” While this is a specific quote referring to Baggio, this can be true for almost all legends. Pele had his famous world cup victory as a 17 year old in Sweden ’58, his leg breaking, and coming back fitter than ever to triumphantly take home the world cup back to Brazil for the third time to permanently keep it there. Maradona had his amazingly dominant Mexico ’86 world cup, and his constant controversial dismissals from football for testing positive for several illegal substances. Zidane will be remembered for his France ’98 triumph and his two headers, as well as his volley against Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League final a few years back. Baggio had his amazing drama story of leading his country to the world cup final in USA ’94 and famously, or rather, infamously missing the penalty to let slip what was so nearly in Italy’s grasp. And so on and so on. Of course with hardcore football enthusiasts it will be different but when you mention a legendary name nobody will say “oh is that the guy with 1281 career goals and eleven Sao Paulo championships?” or “oh are you talking about that guy who won the Serie A championship ’94-’95 with Juventus?” No, you are most likely to hear “yes the guy who missed the penalty and lost us the world cup” or “yea that’s the guy who put the ball in the net with his hands!” Memorable moments give great players everlasting impressions on people’s minds and elevate them to the status of legends.
Lastly we come to another crucial factor in determining whether a player is a legend or just another good player. Let’s take a look at two other examples here, this time, goalkeepers. First example is Kahn and second example is Yashin. Now I am pretty sure if I were to walk up to any football fan and asked them to choose between the two they would probably say Lev Yashin hands down. But does time play a factor in predetermining the perspectives we gain on the “greatness” of players? My opinion is yes. Lev Yashin is a legendary goalkeeper and possibly the best of all time, and being that he had played in an era so long ago, he has faded away into memory and this gave him the status of “legendary” and not just a great goalkeeper. He has become more like a myth, this all-great goalkeeper, with an image imprinted in our minds of this brick wall, an impenetrable force, someone more immortal than human. Looking at Oliver Kahn now, we’ve a much clearer conception of him as we have the luxury of being able to evaluate his performance week in week out if we wished to. We can see his mistakes, we can see his blunders, and realize he is just human. But, Oliver Kahn was undoubtedly one of the, if not
the best goalkeeper of our era (or the era which has just passed). Could it not be possible that in another few decades we could look back on Kahn and see
him as this “all-great legend”? Of course it’s possible, and in fact I believe that that is what
will happen. It is even possible that Kahn or others who followed after him such as Cech, Buffon, and etc. are just as good as or perhaps even better than Yashin but time has shrouded the legends of the past with a cloud of fog and lifted them perhaps above where they
should be.
There are many factors which could determine if we see a player as “legendary” or not. As aforementioned, skills are an important attribute to not only being a football legend but a professional footballer, period. Also, legends cannot be built merely on skill levels, achievements, titles and honours. Legends will have memorable moments in their careers which will have people talking about them for years to come, whether they are of the positive sorts or the opposite. Lastly, Legends, like wine, only get better with age – or so we perceive them to be. The more time that has passed, chances are, the more we will revere them as the pure epitome of the beautiful game. We will forget they are humans and recognize them more as … well … legends, sometimes making them out to be far better than perhaps they truly were. But in the end, what
really makes a legend? It is within
our own perception that legends become what they are. Some of us see certain players as legends; others see them as merely great players. Beckham certainly has fair amounts of skills, he has certainly had his fair share of memorable moments, but will
he be remembered as a football legend in years to come? It is up to us to either remember his brilliant crossing, free kicks, corners, and long range passing or to remember his celebrity status to deem him merely an ultra-popular, popstar/footballer. The same would go for most other players as well, in the end, after all that has to be considered has been considered.