To be honest, I had something different in mind from what has been posted.
Here is my idea...
Have the BF logo in the middle, then have two popular footballers on the left side and then two popular freestylers on the right side.
This way it shows the forum as a freestyle and football forum. Then you can just add Beyond Football forum on the bottom with pretty simple text. Below that, or anywhere else for that matter, say "former Soccer Grip".
I hope that makes sense. I think all 4 of the players should face the BF logo.