Author Topic: Ethan want's everyone to comment in an enthusiastic and motivating way  (Read 5196 times)

Offline BigMac

  • APATW & PMATW
  • *****
  • Posts: 3,722
  • Reputation: 4972
    • View Profile
Glad we have all been taught a lesson on respect.

Tupac this is for you:

Aretha Franklin - Respect (1990)

Offline TF

  • Freestyle Moderator
  • PATW & LTATW
  • ****
  • Posts: 1,659
  • Reputation: 2162
    • View Profile
What Ethan is getting at, is that once upon a time, people actually put time and effort to comment on each others videos. No matter whether it was a beginner level 1 minute training video, or a Legend - Quatro Styles 10 minute production the majority of comments consisted of at least a few sentences explaining the stuff that was a pleasure to watch but also mentioning things that need improvement.

Relating this topic to myself, I used to get 3-4 pages of comments on every single video I made. The difference in skill level I had then compared to the level I have acquired now is absolutely huge, yet my latest video struggled to get 2 pages if I remember correctly.

Its obviously not all about comments, but over the last few months/year the whole freestyle community seems to have completely lost the fun spark it used to have. The entire mentality of new freestylers has shifted dramatically from making really nice videos with well planned out combos, to just trying to throw as many amatw/matw nt in as possible at the complete sacrifice of style. As well as this, freestyles seems to have been squeezed into a tiny box and gives new freestylers the message that hardcore>everything. Because of this, very few are prepared to learn the basics anymore and will do anything to skip the cue. I will often see patw in a video alongside a 10 trick atw htw combo done with horrific style, which imo, is pointless.

I think one of the biggest factors which has resulted in the current state Ethan is talking about, is the introduction of ignorant beginners who are not prepared to shut the fuck up talking nonsense on the internet and train. When I first started, I looked up to people like Palle, Rocco, FX and had full respect for them as freestylers. I remember Rocco and Palle in particular were always willing to reply to any questions I had no matter how retarded and I would always take on board everything that was said. Where as these days, it seems people aren't prepared to listen to advice and have absolutely no respect for those who have been in the game a lot longer than themselves.

Sorry for all the ranting in this post but I had to let it all out!

Peeeeazzz

Offline DanTheMan

  • Moderator
  • APATW & PMATW
  • ****
  • Posts: 3,510
  • Reputation: 4870
    • View Profile
TF just dropped a fucking bomb of knowledge on you bitches!!

its absolutely true.. i remember when even I made a decent video, my 2 years of freestyle, it got SIX pages.. now it would struggle to get two. we need to motivate the people who are starting up.. and yeah, nobody seems to respect the legends these days..
the new guys dont even admire rocco palle azun séan etc the way they should.

anyway as someone whos been on this site over 2 years and is an admin, im gonna make a bigger effort starting today to comment on as many vids as possible with some constructive criticism and some good points and i encourage everyone else to do the same. lets not be the ones who let freestyle lose its fun

Offline Royal Freakiness

  • APATW & PMATW
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,145
  • Reputation: 8086
  • a.k.a. birchissaud (-_-)
    • View Profile
@ TF and Dan's last comments:
sick stuff.

Offline tbc

  • New Shit
  • ****
  • Posts: 991
  • Reputation: 1091
    • View Profile
lets not be the ones who let freestyle lose its fun

:great:
The nitrophosphate process (also known as the Odda process) was a method for the industrial production of nitrogen fertilizers invented by Erling Johnson in the city of Odda, Norway around 1927.

Offline biyan0

  • New Shit
  • ****
  • Posts: 619
  • Reputation: 886
    • View Profile
this is a forum guys this is what is all abou comment debate and give criticism  no matter if they´r some asskissing dude´s

Offline L_I_S

  • Moderator
  • APATW & PMATW
  • ****
  • Posts: 5,118
  • Reputation: 6249
    • View Profile
I think I'm too lazy to make longer comments now. I can't even be stuffed replying to half the shit in this thread. I mean, I agree and what not..but what are you going to do? Force people to comment on every video they watch and type up a paragraph on what they enjoyed?
I don't think I even saw MP reply to one post regaurding how amazing his progress was in his first year yet everyone kept commenting. He didn't even fucking read the comments. I saw this a lot(not only from MP) and I guess that's where I lost my passion to comment with enthusiasm.
I'll try to keep my comments as enthusiastic from now on and I hope others follow suit.

Should comments like 'sick vid' be removed?
http://www.youtube.com/user/LISdafreestyler
-Don't break combos.
-Don't use crossovers to save combos.
-If you're a new freestyler looking to improve, check the stickys in the help and advice section.
-Send me a personal message if you see spam.

Offline BigMac

  • APATW & PMATW
  • *****
  • Posts: 3,722
  • Reputation: 4972
    • View Profile
removing comments is not the solution, if someone kept removing my comments then I would stop commenting full stop.

Offline IWannaBeChuckNorris

  • 360 & NATW
  • **
  • Posts: 155
  • Reputation: 305
    • View Profile
I think I'm too lazy to make longer comments now. I can't even be stuffed replying to half the shit in this thread. I mean, I agree and what not..but what are you going to do? Force people to comment on every video they watch and type up a paragraph on what they enjoyed?
I don't think I even saw MP reply to one post regaurding how amazing his progress was in his first year yet everyone kept commenting. He didn't even fucking read the comments. I saw this a lot(not only from MP) and I guess that's where I lost my passion to comment with enthusiasm.
I'll try to keep my comments as enthusiastic from now on and I hope others follow suit.

Should comments like 'sick vid' be removed?

maybe whenever you see a comment like that just tell them to step it up and link them to this topic  :grin:
and I agree that the comments today aren't what they used to be

Offline L_I_S

  • Moderator
  • APATW & PMATW
  • ****
  • Posts: 5,118
  • Reputation: 6249
    • View Profile
removing comments is not the solution, if someone kept removing my comments then I would stop commenting full stop.
Would a warning be better? If that's not the solution, what do you suggest?
http://www.youtube.com/user/LISdafreestyler
-Don't break combos.
-Don't use crossovers to save combos.
-If you're a new freestyler looking to improve, check the stickys in the help and advice section.
-Send me a personal message if you see spam.

Offline Ethan

  • Freestyle Moderator
  • New Shit
  • ****
  • Posts: 832
  • Reputation: 1293
    • View Profile
tom summarised it perfect (Y)

as for ameremexincan or w.e give him a ban warning for spam. also i think if people are gonna make a special effort to leave proper comments again people won't leave 'cool vid' comments as they will look so out of place

Offline BigMac

  • APATW & PMATW
  • *****
  • Posts: 3,722
  • Reputation: 4972
    • View Profile
removing comments is not the solution, if someone kept removing my comments then I would stop commenting full stop.
Would a warning be better? If that's not the solution, what do you suggest?

What chuck norris said I guess