I did some more research:
the Muay Thai roundhouse kick and the karate/tkd roundhouse kick are basically different techniques
also the roundhouse kick was only introduced to shotokan karate in 1950 :saywhat:
yea. muay thai one is much stronger but slower and easier to anticipate and counter.
and wow.... 1950? lol
I think taht if you can't land a technique, it doesn't matter how much power you have.
thats why tkd/karate roundhouse > muay thai roundhouse
it's easier to land
no way man, that's a dumb thing to say. it always depends on the situation. i know both techniques very well and i use both techniques equally in different situations.
the greater the speed of the technique, and the less the telegraph of the wind up (the muay thai kick has more telegraph) then the greater the likelihood of connecting. Without a doubt, the Muay Thai kick is better once you connect with it, but having seen in in fights and videos, etc, it seems to be slightly easier to evade, because if you see it coming, you have a plit second longer to take a quick step backwards
on the other hand it's harder to dodge because of it's greater roundness
I phrased myself badly there...I think that if you DON'T land a kick, then it doesn't matter how much power you have
connecting on the kick is the first priority, and if there's a bit less power, I'd make that sacrifice
this is not to say that you can't connect on a muay thai roundhouse kick...it's just harder to do